Each product is independently selected by (obsessed) editors.Your purchases through our links may earn us a commission.

Each product is independently selected by (obsessed) editors.Your purchases through our links may earn us a commission.
At Strategist, we like to think we’re crazy about what we buy (in a good way), but we can’t try everything despite our desire.That’s why we have People’s Choice, where we find the best rated products and pick out the most convincing ones.(You can learn more about our scoring system and how we pick each item here.)
While we’ve written about a lot of kitchen tools — including the best kitchen knives, coffee makers, and even the best cutlery racks — here we’ve rounded up the best colanders with some of the most enthusiastic reviewers on Amazon compliment.
Out of nearly 3 good reviewers, many said they liked the colander because it’s big, sturdy, and has lots of tiny holes that let you filter everything from fruit to pasta to rice.One reviewer expressed his love for the Bellemain colander, saying: “Wow, I didn’t start describing this colander. There are a few things in my life that make my life complete: my wife and kids , my home, and now this colander. From the round shape to the holes with stars in the sky, it’s just perfect. The way the water flows through the holes is truly amazing.” Another satisfied customer wrote: “I am very Loved this colander so I ordered a second one. I didn’t realize it would make a difference, but it drains better and is easier to clean than my old plastic OXO colander.” 3rd commenter Explains: “I would buy this as a gift for someone because it’s so sturdy; the holes are small enough that you can drain whatever is in it (though I haven’t tried quinoa), let alone it It looks beautiful. Oh, and big!”
Reviewers have called this colander “heavy duty” over and over again.Many also said they chose it because of its low price and were pleasantly surprised by the quality.”When moving into my house, I needed to buy several major kitchen items and didn’t want to spend a fortune per product. This one caught my eye because of its price point,” explained one reviewer, adding Added, “But I’ve had it for a few months now and it still looks brand new and it does the job really well!” Another reviewer said, “This colander is very sturdy, heavy, and Will definitely last. Sadly, my previous colander had small holes in the lattice structure that weakened and cracked over time, defeating the purpose.” They noted, “While the holes are quite large, this Works great for me. It’s great for washing and rinsing fruits and vegetables.” The delighted customer wrote: “I expected it to be more fragile due to the cheap price, but it’s a sturdy product that will withstand Pretty heavy rinsing material.”
Many reviewers report that this stainless steel colander “drains quickly” and is “easy to clean.”One reviewer who appreciated the silicone handle and tiny feet said: “This is a really nice colander and I’m glad I chose this brand and size. It’s sturdy and I love the look and function. It also has a very nice Handle and comfortable grip. I love that I can put it in the sink and the bottom doesn’t touch the sink. The pasta drains well in it.” Another commenter said: “I love OXO products, the brand is always so Reliable and durable, this colander is no exception. The colander is one piece, which is a huge positive in my book (I once broke my hand while draining potatoes).” Complimented by this satisfied shopper The small holes “allow the water to drain quickly while keeping my pasta in the colander.” They add that the heavy-duty construction also allows for different uses: “Because the feet are silicone, I don’t have to Worry about putting the colander with the pasta back in the pot with a little boiling water on the bottom as a steamer/warmer.”
More than one reviewer used the word “durable” to describe this plastic colander, with one saying: “I absolutely love this colander! I’m one of those people who is picky, even if my sink is clean, Can get sick of putting a colander in the sink, so this really helped me.” Another reviewer who prefers a plastic colander over a metal one especially likes this, “because it’s easy to clean , and best of all, it has feet that lift the colander from the kitchen sink. Overall, the colander is very good quality. I like the weight and thickness of the hard plastic used so it won’t break if dropped. A third satisfied OXO customer called the colander “a treasured workhorse in my kitchen, better than any other filter I’ve ever used. Thank you, OXO, for making such a sturdy, stylish filter!”
“Simple” is a word often used to describe this filter, which attaches to many different sized pots.One reviewer called it “the best kitchen gadget I’ve bought in a long time! I’ve tried it on several pots and pans sizes and it works great every time. It’s easier than a traditional colander Much more! Even my skeptical husband loves it now.” Another happy commenter admitted: “I received one as a wedding gift and was a little skeptical that it would work. I was wrong. It worked perfectly. I can use it on my large and small pots. It clips easily and pulls fast. I use it to strain boiled potatoes and noodles. It’s easy to clean without being overly bulky.” In a review titled “Pasta Game Changer”, one reviewer said, “Well, this stuff is awesome. I don’t know I’ve ever written a review on anything other than a book or movie, but I like it enough make change.”
Because of the fineness of the mesh, the reviews for this mesh colander with handle are full of comments about straining and rinsing rice, quinoa and even grits.”I needed a quinoa strainer with finer mesh than mine so that both rice and quinoa could pass through those holes. This is perfect,” marvels one reviewer, adding, “It drains well and doesn’t allow any runaways.” Another satisfied commenter wrote: “I’m glad the grid is very good. I cook clams a lot and this strainer filters out the clams when I shell them. Most of the sand in the juice. I hate throwing away clam juice, so this is important to me. Fine, good quality metal and mesh.” Another reviewer attests, “It’s great for quinoa and rinsed rice, which Those are two things we’ve done with it within two days of having it.”
Best of all, reviewers love that this colander keeps their food off the bottom of the sink.”I’m tired of putting a bowl colander in the bottom of the sink only to have hot pasta water pooling around the bottom of the bowl. It just doesn’t feel right,” one commenter continued, “so I was looking for one that felt more hygienic The colander. This one is perfect. It extends over my large sink and the water flows like lightning fast.” Another 5-star reviewer wrote: “This thing gets in all my Thanksgiving prep Worked out. It held up great. I have a double sink, but a bit smaller than average (my kitchen is from the 70s). Sides pulled out of my sink to leave room – still for larger sinks Works great.” A woman whose husband washes all the produce said, “He’s very happy with it. It fits on one side of our double sink. The adjustment handle fits easily on the garbage disposal.”
From the hundreds of positive reviews for this colander, the biggest takeaway is that it lets you drain hands-free while saving space.”Saw this at a friend’s house and had to buy one,” said one reviewer, explaining that “the arm extends far enough to even fit a farmhouse sink, and is sturdy enough to hold a pot of potatoes. It made me hands free to carry a heavy pot (won’t burn) and keep food from staying in the water.” Another commenter said that despite its small footprint, it’s not a small colander: “When enlarged When folded, it has enough depth to feed a family of seven or a fat Italian plumber. When folded, it stows neatly in a kitchen drawer. The extended handle is a nice touch. It allows to span larger sinks, And because it’s fitted with rubber pads, it won’t slip.” One satisfied customer concluded: “If you’re looking to buy this, chances are you’re in a similar boat to me because your galley storage space is limited, but Knowing if the right size filter isn’t available. In my opinion, this is a perfectly functioning alternative.”
Reviewers love the way this set allows them to choose the right tool for each intense job, and many of them say they prefer the micro-perforated to the traditional mesh colander.”After I put the celery juice in the blender, I use a colander to strain it out. With this set, I can just choose the one that fits in the bowl below and easily press the celery juice through the fiber and the colander,” one commented Home explained, calling them “a large size for every job, easy to clean, stackable, and easy to store.” Another happy reviewer called them “great.”I can see that I haven’t wasted my money.I especially like the fact that there is no place for any extra food to hide during cleaning, but the structure is heavy duty.The stainless steel mesh is small enough to keep small items from falling out, but strong enough to handle heavy food items and still allow water to escape easily.Plus, they look good as a set, according to one reviewer, “My husband and I really love these!”Lightweight and hangs beautifully on our pot racks – easy access while cooking.”
By submitting your email, you agree to our terms and privacy statement and to receive email communications from us.
The Strategist aims to provide the most useful expert advice on what to buy in the vast e-commerce environment.Some of our latest results include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, side sleeping pillows, natural anxiety remedies and bath towels.We will update the link whenever possible, but please note that deals may expire and all prices are subject to change.
Each editorial product is independently selected.New York may receive an affiliate commission if you purchase through our links.
Each product is independently selected by (obsessed) editors.Your purchases through our links may earn us a commission.